Politics & Government

Mayor Nutter to Whitemarsh: Close Down That Road

The dispute over Hagys Mill Road has come to an end after Mayor Nutter stepped in.

After an ultimatium from Philadelphia Mayor Michael Nutter, the Whitemarsh Board of Supervisors agreed to close off a disputed gate for most of the week, slowing traffic between Andorra and the suburbs.

In a recent meeting with Whitemarsh Board of Supervisors Chair Robert Hart at Philadelphia's City Hall, Hart says Mayor Nutter gave the township an ultimatum: close the gate except for eight hours a week, or the city would block off emergency services.

Hart took option A.

Find out what's happening in Roxborough-Manayunkwith free, real-time updates from Patch.

The road has been at the ever since it was opened for the first time in decades after Hurricane Irene washed out Manor Road last August.

Nearby residents were left with little option to exit their neighborhood, particularly when heading east into Philadelphia. Whitemarsh officials decided to open the gate, enabling those residents to head directly east rather than having to travel southwest to River Road and then north on Harts Lane all the way to Ridge Pike.

Find out what's happening in Roxborough-Manayunkwith free, real-time updates from Patch.

However, it didn't take long for word to get out about the new shortcut from Montgomery County to Philadelphia. Traffic increased.

One Philadelphia resident that the gate was originally closed "to ensure that the rural character of the area would be safeguarded from undue traffic, and that Hagys Mill Road would not become a back-channel thru-way from Manayunk to Conshohocken or farther. Nearby Whitemarsh and Philadelphia citizens and their children were protected from the hazards of too many vehicles moving too fast along roads that were not meant to bear them."

In addition, the resident wrote that they were originally told the road would be open only for the bussing of children, and that it would be closed by the end of October. Whitemarsh Chief of Police Michael Beaty that the road would remain open until Manor Road was repaired.

While Whitemarsh expects Manor Road to be reopened by July, Hagys Mill is now closed except for 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on Tuesdays and Thursdays, after the meeting with the Mayor.

"I went with our solicitor down to City Hall, and the Mayor came out and was very direct," said Hart at last month's Whitemarsh Supervisors meeting. "He said Tuesday and Thursday, 10 to 2, or I'll put a jersey barrier across it and you'll get no emergency services personnel in or out of there, period."

A Whitemarsh Emergency

Hart explained to Patch that it is difficult for large emergency vehicles to access the area through Whitemarsh controlled roads due to bridges in the area. In a worst-case scenario requiring multiple ladder trucks, access through Philadelphia would be crucial.

"We had some residents say 'fight it, call his bluff,'" said Hart. "But God forbid something were to happen—then that's on me."

One such resident was William Murphy, of 3 Williams Court, whose public comment at the supervisors' meeting sparked the discussion.

"We're just trying to get something for the residents," said Murphy, who proposed an access card gate as one possibility. "They closed off River Road, they closed off Hagys Mill Road—what are they going to do next, close off Ridge Pike and say go to Germantown (Pike)?"

In March, , and promised to install signs discouraging through way traffic—similar to Wises Mill Road at Valley Green in the Wissahickon.

Streets Commissioner Clarena Tolson explained it as a move to slow traffic.

"The Streets Department thanks the citizens in advance for their patience and cooperation and asks that passenger vehicles respect the request to not use the road to access Whitemarsh," Tolson said.

Neighborhood Dispute

Some residents have targeted their ire at two Philadelphia residents just on the other side of the gate, whom they believe have been in the ears of Philadelphia officials over the dispute. However, those residents say they are being unjustly, and illegally, targeted.

One Andorra resident whom Patch also spoke with at the gate, said that someone had put feces on her walkway and a warning sign from the gate on her front porch. Police were called at least twice: once when in late March, and another when near the Philadelphia homes.

"I don't know why it's become this thing where the people who live here have done wrong to people," she said, freely adding that she was out of the country during the meeting with the mayor. "Everybody bought a cul-de-sac, it was never an open road."

It turns out it might not have taken much to prompt Mayor Nutter to make the decision. Nutter was at the center of many agreements with Whitemarsh during his time as councilman for the adjacent fourth district of Philadelphia, including one that gave township residents access to city utility lines.

However, there may have been a sour moment or two.

"He had a bad experience with Whitemarsh [about] River Road, from his perspective," said Hart. "The city provided Whitemarsh with access to water…and they felt they were very giving to Whitemarsh, that they were being a good neighbor, and Whitemarsh wasn't being. That's their perspective."

So for now, Nutter has the final say: 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on Tuesday and Thursday. And until Manor Road reopens this summer, Whitemarsh residents are out of luck.


Get more local news delivered straight to your inbox. Sign up for free Patch newsletters and alerts.

We’ve removed the ability to reply as we work to make improvements. Learn more here